Searching Shelter Island, New York or Change Locations

Who are you looking for?I am a Man seeking a WomanI am a Woman seeking a ManI am a Man seeking a ManI am a Woman seeking a Woman18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80+ All Miles10 Miles30 Miles50 Miles70 Miles100 Miles150 Miles200 Miles300 Miles400 Miles500 Miles

18 in Wilmington, DE
192 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
1 more photo

33 in Manassas, VA
315 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
2 more photos

45 in Boston, MA
111 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
1 more photo

18 in West Virginia , United States
463 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

56 in Wilmington, NC
562 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

18 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

35 in Washington, DC
289 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

32 in Washington, DC
289 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
3 more photos

34 in Ashburn, VA
306 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

30 in Washington, DC
289 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
1 more photo

28 in Newton Falls, OH
450 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

31 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
2 more photos

51 in Philadelphia, PA
167 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Minutes Ago

35 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now

18 in Toronto, Ontario
401 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 17 Minutes Ago

35 in Holtsville, NY
40 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
1 more photo

62 in Waterloo , Canada
450 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 17 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

35 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
3 more photos

58 in Hollsopple, Pennsylvania
351 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 18 Minutes Ago

30 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
1 more photo

75 in Jericho, New York
64 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 27 Minutes Ago

45 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
2 more photos

68 in Hampstead, MD
258 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 44 Minutes Ago

31 in Washington, DC
289 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
3 more photos

25 in New York, NY
87 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 44 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

28 in Secaucus, NJ
92 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
1 more photo

68 in York, PA
244 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 47 Minutes Ago

35 in Charlotte, North Carolina
612 Miles From Shelter Island
Online Now
4 more photos

18 in Holtsville, NY
40 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 53 Minutes Ago

31 in Garland, PA
372 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Minutes Ago
5 more photos

18 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 57 Minutes Ago

40 in Ashburn, VA
306 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Minutes Ago

78 in Williamsburg, VA
351 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 58 Minutes Ago

25 in North Bergen, NJ
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Minutes Ago
7 more photos

18 in Stumpy Point, NC
413 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

35 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 7 Minutes Ago

36 in North Bergen, NJ
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

34 in Keller, VA
300 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 8 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

19 in Blairstown, NJ
137 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

59 in New York, NY
90 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 10 Minutes Ago
1 more photo

18 in New Haven, CT
33 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

30 in Randallstown, MD
262 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 10 Minutes Ago

74 in Stamford, CT
63 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

27 in Brooklandville, MD
255 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 12 Minutes Ago

59 in Irvington, New Jersey
102 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago
2 more photos

20 in New York, New York
90 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 13 Minutes Ago

58 in Milton, Delaware
224 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

29 in Brooklyn , New York
88 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 13 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

56 in Long Island City, NY
87 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

35 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 14 Minutes Ago

27 in New York, NY
91 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

18 in Amherst, MA
93 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 15 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

18 in Toms River, NJ
124 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

37 in Spartanburg, SC
675 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 17 Minutes Ago

75 in Torrington, CT
66 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago

30 in Washington, DC
289 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 18 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

68 in Jersey City, NJ
92 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 1 Hour ago
3 more photos

18 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 18 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

51 in Massillon, Ohio
481 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 2 Hours ago

18 in New York , USA
90 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 20 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

18 in New York, NY
90 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 2 Hours ago
2 more photos

23 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 20 Minutes Ago
9 more photos

47 in Fall River, Massachusetts
76 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 2 Hours ago
1 more photo

31 in Burkeville, VA
412 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 23 Minutes Ago
1 more photo

18 in Philadelphia, PA
167 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 2 Hours ago

33 in Yonkers, NY
82 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 25 Minutes Ago
1 more photo

18 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 2 Hours ago

30 in Sewaren, NJ
106 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 26 Minutes Ago
4 more photos

47 in Fall River, Massachusetts
76 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 2 Hours ago

36 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 27 Minutes Ago

18 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 3 Hours ago

24 in North Bergen, NJ
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 28 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

64 in Middletown, CT
38 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 3 Hours ago

27 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 31 Minutes Ago

69 in Baldwin, New York
72 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 3 Hours ago
2 more photos

30 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 34 Minutes Ago

68 in Woodstock, NY
115 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 4 Hours ago

30 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 36 Minutes Ago
1 more photo

57 in Washington, District of Columbia
285 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 4 Hours ago
4 more photos

31 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 37 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

43 in Conneaut, OH
429 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 4 Hours ago

41 in Derry, NH
136 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 38 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

18 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 4 Hours ago
1 more photo

40 in Ashburn, VA
306 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 39 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

70 in Ingersoll, Ontario
459 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 4 Hours ago

40 in Machipongo, VA
316 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 40 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

52 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 4 Hours ago

28 in New York, NY
89 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 43 Minutes Ago

30 in New York , New York
90 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Hours ago
1 more photo

30 in Ashburn, VA
306 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 44 Minutes Ago
2 more photos

18 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Hours ago

32 in Stafford, VA
322 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 45 Minutes Ago
3 more photos

61 in Toronto, Ontario
401 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Hours ago

31 in Toronto, Ontario
401 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 48 Minutes Ago

56 in Schenectady, NY
148 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Hours ago

28 in Virginia Beach, VA
358 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 52 Minutes Ago

55 in Bridgeville, PA
410 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Hours ago

29 in Youngstown, OH
430 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 52 Minutes Ago

47 in Gaithersburg, Maryland
286 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 5 Hours ago

30 in Ashburn, VA
306 Miles From Shelter Island
Online 55 Minutes Ago